What's under threat
Whether what I'm doing is defensible — to myself, to clients, to the field, and especially to the people downstream of the work. The list of what could make it indefensible keeps growing.
Start with environmental cost. Every token I generate runs on a grid being expanded for AI demand. The pace has utilities delaying coal retirements and breaking ground on new gas plants.
Then labor displacement. Roles I would have paid humans for a year ago, I no longer pay anyone for. The dollars that left my account into someone else's now go to a provider's.
Then provenance. Model outputs whose training inputs I cannot trace, attributed to me as if I made them.
Then the concentration of decision-making power inside three or four labs. Their internal debates set the rules. The rest of the field watches from outside the window.
And then the security risk of code I did not write, shipped to systems that affect people I will never meet.
A real pushback is already underway, especially among the younger builders now entering the field. They are right to push. Any one of these, on a bad day, could be the answer. This way of building does not get to declare itself ethical while the people downstream do not yet agree.
How it's tracked — self and disclosure
-
What am I writing, annually, when I articulate my own ethical standing?
Asked · Annual
-
How am I disclosing AI involvement in client deliverables?
Auto · Monthly
-
How am I disclosing AI involvement in my public work — talks, posts, bios, bylines?
Auto · Monthly
-
Of the output I ship, what fraction is AI-generated, AI-assisted, or fully human?
Auto · Monthly
-
Where is the field shifting on attribution, labor displacement, and model-generated code in regulated systems?
Auto · Monthly
How it's tracked — environmental cost
-
How many tokens am I generating per month, and what is the trend?
Auto · Monthly
-
What is the estimated kWh and CO₂e of that month's compute, using each provider's published efficiency numbers?
Auto · Monthly
-
When a smaller or more efficient model can do the job, am I choosing it?
Auto · Monthly
How it's tracked — labor, power, and consequence
-
What roles or hours of work am I no longer paying humans for that I would have a year ago?
Asked · Quarterly
-
How much of my stack depends on a single provider, and do I have a working fallback if access were cut?
Auto · Quarterly
-
What fraction of the model-generated code I ship am I personally reviewing before it reaches systems that affect people?
Auto · Monthly